A Google user
Trying to describe this book as either 'good' or 'bad' is giving me a headache, mainly because, even though it has some merit, I would probably not recommend it to anyone, except if he/she needed to read it as a class requirement. So I'll just describe what I liked and what I didn't like:
I liked most of the language and the literary structures of the novel. Some of the most interesting passages are of the four men deciding what to do with the killed body, the action-packed scenes of the river-rapids, and Ed's (highly improbable, yet poetic) climbing of the cliff. I also liked the strong influence of nature/animal/wilderness themes.
I did not like (and at some points, couldn't stand) the very awkward dialogue, which seemed out of place in some situations; the imagery and metaphysical description (such as of dreams and the deer-hunting scene), although well-written and captivating, were dragged-out and at first difficult to reconstruct in the fast-paced, danger-filled plot.
What caught me off-guard somewhat, though I can extract the reason for it being there, are the occasional references/nuances of homoerotism. So, I can understand that Dickey includes these to strengthen the themes of male bonding and to construct a notion of the ideal "alpha male", yet it also seems out-of-place from the dangerous trek that these suburbanites are experiencing. Or maybe, it is appropriate, probably to reveal an absurd type of suburban mindset that blindly focuses on what it is to be a man, namely the sexual side. I have no idea, really. That's why this book gives me a headache.
The book overall leads to some interesting class discussions that could be equally done, if not better, with similarly-themed books like "The Lord of the Flies" and such. It may also offer some insight into what it means to be a suburban man caught in a life-or-death situation. I found that last sentence hard to write. Read it only if you have to. Or watch the movie.
Enrico Cheatham
I have seen the film several times over the years and have finally read the book.I thought this story was well crafted and captivating. Four city men head to the country for a weekend of canoeing down the river and endure a harrowing experience. A significant contemplation on the intangibles one has to possess in order to survive without the comforts of modern civilization.
Brian Siis
Having seen the movie,I could picture visually each character and the scene as its happening.
2 people found this review helpful